Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
151 lines (122 loc) · 4.24 KB

stdio_versus_sse_mcp_servers.md

File metadata and controls

151 lines (122 loc) · 4.24 KB

Understanding MCP Server Types: STDIO vs SSE

Overview

The Model Control Protocol (MCP) supports two types of servers: STDIO (Standard Input/Output) and SSE (Server-Sent Events). Each has its own characteristics, setup requirements, and security implications. This guide will help you understand the differences and choose the right option for your needs.

Quick Comparison

Feature STDIO SSE
Communication Method Process pipes HTTP/HTTPS
Setup Complexity Simple Moderate
Security Model Process-level isolation Web security model
Deployment Local only Local or remote
State Management New process per call Persistent connection
Resource Usage Higher (new process each time) Lower (persistent connection)

STDIO Servers

What is STDIO?

STDIO servers communicate through standard input/output streams of a process. They're basically command-line programs that follow the MCP protocol for communication.

Advantages

  • Simple to implement and debug
  • Natural process isolation
  • Works well with existing CLI tools
  • No network configuration needed
  • Great for local development

Challenges

  • Must manage process lifecycle
  • Higher resource overhead (new process per call)
  • Limited to local machine
  • Requires proper environment setup (Python, node, etc.)
  • Need to handle PYTHONUNBUFFERED and other environment variables

Setup Requirements

  1. Python or Node.js installed locally
  2. Proper PATH configuration
  3. Environment variables (especially PYTHONUNBUFFERED='1')
  4. Command must be executable from shell

Security Considerations

  • Process-level isolation provides natural security boundary
  • Security depends on file system permissions
  • Need to carefully handle environment variables
  • No network exposure by design

SSE Servers

What is SSE?

SSE servers use HTTP/HTTPS with Server-Sent Events for bi-directional communication. They're web servers that implement the MCP protocol over HTTP.

Advantages

  • Persistent connections (better performance)
  • Can be accessed remotely
  • Standard web security model
  • Easier to scale
  • Better for production deployments

Challenges

  • More complex to set up
  • Requires proper HTTP/HTTPS configuration
  • Need to handle web security concerns
  • Must manage connection state
  • Requires network configuration

Setup Requirements

  1. Web server configuration
  2. SSL/TLS certificates (for HTTPS)
  3. Proper network/firewall configuration
  4. URL and port management
  5. Authentication/authorization setup

Security Considerations

  • Must implement proper web security measures
  • Need HTTPS for production use
  • Authentication/authorization required for remote access
  • Cross-Origin Resource Sharing (CORS) configuration
  • Network-level security measures needed

Best Practices

When to Use STDIO

  • Local development
  • CLI tools
  • Simple integrations
  • When process isolation is important
  • Testing and debugging

When to Use SSE

  • Production deployments
  • Remote access needed
  • Scaling requirements
  • Long-running connections
  • When performance is critical

Common Issues and Solutions

STDIO Issues

  1. Process hanging

    • Solution: Set PYTHONUNBUFFERED='1'
    • Ensure proper stream flushing

  2. Path problems

    • Solution: Configure full path in commands
    • Set up proper environment variables

SSE Issues

  1. Connection timeouts

    • Solution: Configure proper timeout settings
    • Implement reconnection logic

  2. CORS errors

    • Solution: Configure proper CORS headers
    • Use appropriate security policies

Example Configuration

{
  "mcpServers": {
    "local-stdio": {
      "type": "stdio",
      "command": "python",
      "args": ["server.py"],
      "env": {
        "PYTHONUNBUFFERED": "1"
      }
    },
    "remote-sse": {
      "type": "sse",
      "url": "https://api.example.com/mcp",
      "headers": {
        "Authorization": "Bearer token"
      }
    }
  }
}

Getting Started

  1. Choose your server type based on your needs
  2. Follow the setup requirements for your chosen type
  3. Configure environment and security settings
  4. Test with simple tool calls
  5. Monitor for any issues
  6. Scale as needed

Remember: Start with STDIO for development and testing, then move to SSE for production if needed.